Hey Brooklyn! Get started with $20 off your first subscription of $40 or more.

Lessons from the Top: Why Some Restaurants Flourish While Others Fail

Lessons from the Top: Why Some Restaurants Flourish While Others Fail

TLDR

If you're an entrepreneur, you know that success is never guaranteed. Even with the tastiest dishes and trendiest decor, some restaurants fail during their first year. By examining what separates thriving establishments from failing ones, you gain valuable lessons on how to steer your restaurant toward prosperity. From leveraging technology to optimizing customer experience, this article explores the key differences in vision, adaptability, and execution that allow some eateries to flourish while others falter. You will learn critical insights from successful restaurants on how to future-proof and grow your business in a competitive industry. With the thoughtful application of these strategies, your restaurant can avoid common pitfalls and become the neighborhood favorite.

Why Site Selection Is Critical for Restaurants

Demographic Research Determines Target Customers

Conducting thorough demographic research of potential sites helps determine a restaurant’s target customer base. Analyzing population density, income levels, and customer traffic enables owners to tailor their concept and menu to community needs. Major restaurant chains often rely on advanced site selection software and analytics for choosing optimal locations based on demographic data. For independents, basic research into a neighborhood’s residential and commercial makeup is essential.

The Right Location Impacts Profitability and Customer Experience

Selecting the right location can make or break a restaurant’s success. An easily accessible, visible site in a high-traffic area will attract more customers and boost profitability. Meanwhile, a poor location hampers visibility and convenience, damaging the customer experience. Restaurateurs should evaluate parking availability, public transit options, and pedestrian traffic flows. They should also consider nearby businesses, as proximity to complementary establishments may increase patronage.

Competing Successfully Depends on Location

The location also determines the level of competition a restaurant faces, which significantly impacts success. Areas with few comparable dining options present opportunities to capture an underserved market. However, limited competition often indicates lower customer demand. Restaurants in oversaturated markets struggle to differentiate themselves and win customers amid intense competition. The most successful restaurants choose locations that balance adequate demand with reasonable competition. With the right site and concept, they can gain a competitive advantage and thrive.

Lack of Vision Dooms Many Restaurants to Failure

A Clear Vision is Key to Success

Successful restaurants thrive due to a well-defined vision and business ethos. This clarity of purpose allows them to make strategic decisions, maintain high standards of quality, and build a loyal customer base. In contrast, restaurants without a vision struggle with inconsistency and lack of identity. According to a Cornell University study, lack of vision is the top reason new restaurants fail.

Technology and Innovation

Thriving restaurants utilize technology and social media to understand customers, streamline operations, and improve the overall experience. Mobile apps, an engaging website, and active social media profiles are the norm. In contrast, failing restaurants are stuck in the past, relying on outdated methods and failing to connect with modern diners.

Focus on Customer Experience

Successful restaurants recognize that a great customer experience builds loyalty and word-of-mouth marketing. From knowledgeable staff to high-quality ingredients to an inviting ambiance, every detail is optimized. Failing restaurants, on the other hand, provide mediocre or inconsistent experiences, leaving customers unlikely to return.

Adaptability

The restaurant industry is constantly changing, so success requires the ability to adapt. Thriving restaurants stay on the cutting edge of trends, updating their menus, style, and operations to match current tastes. In contrast, failing restaurants stubbornly stick to the status quo, even as customer preferences evolve around them. Ultimately, a lack of vision and unwillingness to change doom many restaurants to failure. Success requires clarity of purpose, innovation, a focus on customer experience, and the ability to adapt to an ever-changing industry.

Investing in Technology Like Restaurant POS Systems to Streamline Operations

Upgrading your technology systems is crucial for thriving restaurants.POS software and mobile apps provide an efficient way to handle daily operations.

Streamlining the Ordering Process

With a quick-service POS system, servers can spend less time manually processing orders and payments, freeing up time to improve customer service. Customers can also place orders and pay through user-friendly mobile apps and websites, reducing wait times.

Enhancing Inventory Management

A robust POS platform gives managers real-time insight into ingredient levels, sales, and waste to control food costs effectively. The software can also automate purchasing and send alerts when supplies are low to avoid shortages.

Gaining Valuable Insights

Advanced reporting and analytics tools provide data on customer habits, popular menu items, and operational bottlenecks. Restaurateurs can then make informed decisions about marketing, menu changes, and staffing to boost revenue and cut costs.

Offering Engaging Loyalty Programs

Restaurants can establish personalized connections with customers through integrated loyalty programs like Square's. Targeted promotions and rewards based on order history and preferences will keep guests coming back.

While technology cannot single-handedly save a failing restaurant, it provides the tools and insights to improve critical areas like customer service, cost control, and operational efficiency—which ultimately separate the thriving from the struggling. Restaurateurs unwilling to invest in and leverage advanced systems will find it difficult to gain a competitive advantage in today’s market. Though the initial financial outlay may seem steep, the long-term benefits to the bottom line are well worth the cost.

Building a Loyal Customer Base Through Excellent Service

Superior Hospitality

Restaurants that cultivate loyalty emphasize hospitality and customer experience. Staff greet customers warmly, smile, make eye contact, and engage in friendly conversation. They learn customers’ names, preferences, and stories, conveying a personal touch. When staff shows genuine care and interest, customers feel valued. Successful restaurants also encourage staff to anticipate needs and resolve issues promptly. These meaningful interactions transform customers into loyal advocates.

Consistency and Quality

Successful restaurants focus on consistency and high quality in both food and service. They have efficient systems and well-trained staff to ensure customers receive the same outstanding experience with each visit. Their menus feature high-quality, flavorful ingredients prepared skillfully. Staff pay close attention to details, such as checking in on customers during meals and refilling drinks before they are empty. These factors and reasonable prices give customers a good reason to return frequently.

Feedback and Responsiveness

Leading restaurants actively seek customer feedback and respond promptly to concerns. They distribute surveys, encourage online reviews, and monitor social media for mentions. Managers address issues directly and personally. They value feedback as an opportunity to strengthen relationships, better understand customer needs, and make improvements. By listening and taking action, these restaurants build trust and loyalty.

Pro Tip: Explore the Per Diem app to begin gathering customer reviews directly within the app for every mobile order.

Menu Development Strategies to Attract Customers

Focus on Popular and Profitable Dishes

Successful restaurants strategically promote items that are the most popular and profitable. They analyze sales data to determine which dishes are ordered most frequently and have the highest profit margins. These items are then prominently featured on the menu to attract customers. Failing restaurants often do not have a data-driven approach to menu development and do not optimize the menu to push high-demand, high-profit dishes.

Employ Relative Pricing

Thriving restaurants utilize relative pricing strategies to maximize sales of certain items. This involves pricing dishes relative to each other so that more profitable items seem like a better value. For example, a restaurant may price a high-profit dish slightly lower than similar items to drive customers to choose that option. Failing restaurants typically have an arbitrary approach to pricing that does not consider the relationship between the prices of different menu items.

Offer Plant-Based Options

Chains like Subway and Chipotle cater to current food trends and dietary preferences by providing plant-based meat alternatives and vegetarian menu options. According to various surveys, the number of consumers following plant-based or vegetarian diets is increasing. By offering dishes featuring ingredients like plant-based meat, tofu, and legumes, top restaurants can capture this growing demographic. In contrast, failing restaurants are often slow to adapt to changing consumer tastes and rarely provide menu options specifically geared toward vegetarians or other diet types.

To attract more customers and increase profits, restaurants should focus on optimizing their menu to push popular and profitable items, employing smart relative pricing strategies, and offering on-trend plant-based or vegetarian options. By adopting data-driven techniques used by thriving restaurants, struggling establishments can revamp their menu to better meet customer demand. With an inviting menu featuring appealing options for all diners, any restaurant has the potential to flourish.

Managing Finances and Operations to Drive Growth and Profitability

Effective Budgeting and Financial Planning

To thrive, restaurants must implement disciplined budgeting and financial planning. Create detailed budgets forecasting sales, costs, and cash flow over the next 1-3 years. Analyze historical data to set realistic targets, then track performance monthly and make adjustments as needed. Maintain healthy profit margins, aiming for at least 10% net profit—control costs by monitoring portions, waste, and labor.

Cash Flow Management

Maintaining adequate cash flow is essential for daily operations and ensuring enough liquidity to cover expenses. Analyze cash flow statements regularly to anticipate shortfalls, then make adjustments like reducing costs or increasing sales. Consider opening a line of credit to cover temporary shortages. Poor cash flow management can lead to the inability to pay vendors and employees, damaging relationships and reputations.

Pro Tip: Explore Quickbooks for your business needs, and take advantage of its 30-day free trial.

Increasing Sales and Profitability

Several strategies can increase restaurant profitability. Boost sales volume through marketing and loyalty programs. Decrease controllable expenses like energy usage. Trim food costs by using seasonal ingredients, reducing waste, and accurately pricing menu items based on the cost of goods sold. Using technology like online ordering and payment systems or inventory management software also improves efficiency and cuts costs.

Lacking Key Operational Expertise

Some restaurants struggle from lack of experience in key areas like management, operations, or finance. Owners may have a vision but lack the expertise to execute it. Hire experienced staff, especially for general managers, chefs, and finance roles. Provide ongoing training to build necessary skills. Partnering with a restaurant consultant or management company can also help address experience gaps.

Following these best practices for managing finances, controlling costs, increasing sales, and developing operational expertise is key to achieving growth and long-term profitability. With diligent planning and oversight, thriving restaurants can build a sustainable business model. Those unable to do so risk joining the ranks of failed restaurants.

Final Thoughts

To thrive in this competitive industry, you must provide an exceptional dining experience through quality food, service, ambiance, and technology integration. Invest in your staff through training and support. Create an online presence with an intuitive website and mobile app. Choose a prime location suited to your concept. Most importantly, have a clear vision and passion. Without dedication to your craft, no amount of strategy can save a floundering restaurant. Success comes down to heart. If you love what you do, your guests will know. Keep striving for excellence, and you will flourish.

Explore featured restaurants and cafes

Coffee with a Cause: How Screaming Bean Supports Veterans and the Aberdeen Community
Coffee with a Cause: How Screaming Bean Supports Veterans and the Aberdeen Community
Read Case study
How Fly Boy Blue’s Mobile App Strategy Sets a New Standard for Australian Coffee Shops
How Fly Boy Blue’s Mobile App Strategy Sets a New Standard for Australian Coffee Shops
Read Case study
What Creative Strategies Keep Crave Cookies' Sales Growing Week After Week?
What Creative Strategies Keep Crave Cookies' Sales Growing Week After Week?
Read Case study
Great UX & Unlimited Coffee: Why Fresh Baguette Chose Per Diem Over Craver
Great UX & Unlimited Coffee: Why Fresh Baguette Chose Per Diem Over Craver
Read Case study
How Palace Coffee Co. Achieved a 25% Sales Increase By Switching to Per Diem
How Palace Coffee Co. Achieved a 25% Sales Increase By Switching to Per Diem
Read Case study
What Sets The Bagelers Coffeehouse Apart from Others in Chicago
What Sets The Bagelers Coffeehouse Apart from Others in Chicago
Read Case study
How Dough & Co. Saves Big by Switching to Per Diem for Pizza Deliveries
How Dough & Co. Saves Big by Switching to Per Diem for Pizza Deliveries
Read Case study
How is Primal Bowls Leveraging the Mobile App to Fuel Expansion?
How is Primal Bowls Leveraging the Mobile App to Fuel Expansion?
Read Case study
Why Teaven’s Mobile Ordering Success Is a Model for Other French Tea Brands?
Why Teaven’s Mobile Ordering Success Is a Model for Other French Tea Brands?
Read Case study
How Mid Atlantic Seafood Leverages Per Diem’s App for Higher Delivery Sales
How Mid Atlantic Seafood Leverages Per Diem’s App for Higher Delivery Sales
Read Case study
How Crave Cookies Shifted to Per Diem to Challenge Crumbl
How Crave Cookies Shifted to Per Diem to Challenge Crumbl
Read Case study
Coffee Dose Cafe's Winning Website Strategies for App Promotion
Coffee Dose Cafe's Winning Website Strategies for App Promotion
Read Case study
How Bakeries Like Chip City Use Referral Programs to Increase Customer Counts
How Bakeries Like Chip City Use Referral Programs to Increase Customer Counts
Read Case study
Skip the Line: How Groovy Goose Coffee Streamlined Orders With a Mobile App
Skip the Line: How Groovy Goose Coffee Streamlined Orders With a Mobile App
Read Case study
How Boba Bliss Drove Sales Through Mobile App Coupons
How Boba Bliss Drove Sales Through Mobile App Coupons
Read Case study
What Makes Iron Paffles & Coffee Stand Out in Charlottesville
What Makes Iron Paffles & Coffee Stand Out in Charlottesville
Read Case study
How Kona Coffee Roasters Transformed NYC’s Commuter Coffee Culture with Per Diem
How Kona Coffee Roasters Transformed NYC’s Commuter Coffee Culture with Per Diem
Read Case study
How Kimchi Box Became Michigan's Favorite Restaurant With Mobile Ordering
How Kimchi Box Became Michigan's Favorite Restaurant With Mobile Ordering
Read Case study
How Arkansas' the Busy Bean Tops Charts on Google Play With a Custom Mobile App
How Arkansas' the Busy Bean Tops Charts on Google Play With a Custom Mobile App
Read Case study
How Crema Coffee & Soda is Satisfying Customers in Utah With a Soda Pop App
How Crema Coffee & Soda is Satisfying Customers in Utah With a Soda Pop App
Read Case study
How Lucky Coffee Boosts Mobile App Adoption Through Email Campaigns
How Lucky Coffee Boosts Mobile App Adoption Through Email Campaigns
Read Case study
How Per Diem Helps Oaks Coffee House Give Back to The Chattanooga Community
How Per Diem Helps Oaks Coffee House Give Back to The Chattanooga Community
Read Case study
Run Your Cafe Like a Bank: How Ethereal Cafe Created a Starbucks-Style Mobile App
Run Your Cafe Like a Bank: How Ethereal Cafe Created a Starbucks-Style Mobile App
Read Case study
From One-Timers To Regulars: How Empire Tea and Coffee Transformed Customer Loyalty with Per Diem
From One-Timers To Regulars: How Empire Tea and Coffee Transformed Customer Loyalty with Per Diem
Read Case study
How Cosmic Coffeehouse Teamed Up with Per Diem and Square for an Out-of-This-World Grand Opening
How Cosmic Coffeehouse Teamed Up with Per Diem and Square for an Out-of-This-World Grand Opening
Read Case study
How Kino's Coffee and Others Have Boosted Their Sales with Push Notifications
How Kino's Coffee and Others Have Boosted Their Sales with Push Notifications
Read Case study
Coupon Codes That Work: Chip City's Free Cookie Strategy for Customer Acquisition
Coupon Codes That Work: Chip City's Free Cookie Strategy for Customer Acquisition
Read Case study
From Local Comfort Food to High Tech: How Joanie’s Modernized Operations
From Local Comfort Food to High Tech: How Joanie’s Modernized Operations
Read Case study
Rebranding a Bubble Tea Brand: How Niko Niko Boba Expanded Beyond Chatime
Rebranding a Bubble Tea Brand: How Niko Niko Boba Expanded Beyond Chatime
Read Case study
How Plomo Quesadillas Won Over Gen-Z With Square Loyalty
How Plomo Quesadillas Won Over Gen-Z With Square Loyalty
Read Case study
The Perfect Blend: How Coffee Dose Boosted Brand Loyalty with Per Diem
The Perfect Blend: How Coffee Dose Boosted Brand Loyalty with Per Diem
Read Case study
Ambee Coffee's Rebrand and Per Diem: A Match Made for Expansion
Ambee Coffee's Rebrand and Per Diem: A Match Made for Expansion
Read Case study
Why Kino's Coffee Switched Mobile Apps: A Case Study in Improving the Customer Experience
Why Kino's Coffee Switched Mobile Apps: A Case Study in Improving the Customer Experience
Read Case study
How DoorDash Drive and Per Diem Fueled Masala Wok and Tikka Shack's Delivery Dreams
How DoorDash Drive and Per Diem Fueled Masala Wok and Tikka Shack's Delivery Dreams
Read Case study
Per Diem's Square Integration: How Island Flavor Streamlined Operations
Per Diem's Square Integration: How Island Flavor Streamlined Operations
Read Case study
Hidden Grounds Case Study: When Apps Meet Customer Loyalty, Magic Happens
Hidden Grounds Case Study: When Apps Meet Customer Loyalty, Magic Happens
Read Case study
Scan for a Free Cookie: How Chip City's QR Codes Drove App Adoption
Scan for a Free Cookie: How Chip City's QR Codes Drove App Adoption
Read Case study
Close Line
Try Per Diem
Sign up for our monthly newsletter for all the latest in local restaurant trends, industry insights, and Per Diem product updates.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Close Line

Unlock new insights and trends by
downloading Ultimate Guide for Launching a Mobile Ordering App.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.